Tags
brasil, exploitation, fur, inditex, peta, slave labor, Zara
Since this is a rather critical than “blingbling” kind of fashion blog, I’d like to go a little bit deeper into the field of EXPLOITATION in the fashion industry. Depending on your attitude, this is probably a never ending story, but I want to point out two aspects that I find exceptionally striking.
Fur industry
This video shows how miserably the animals bred for fur are treaded. I believe, seeing this has a significantly bigger impact than simply reading about it. So for those of you who want to know more, especially on the processing of reptiles: see here
So Zara and its mother company Inditex has been critized by fur activist for selling real fur in their stores several times in the last years and claimed 2009 to no longer use fur, but actually they still do like many others. In response to a demonstration in Cologne against fur production verbally attacking INDITEX, the company replied: “All animal products used in those articles supplied to the Group shall come from animal reared in farms to obtain meat.” Apart from this fact being irrelevant, we can also see how the consumers were tricked on purpose and how INDITEX broke it’s word. Though I have to admit, I’ve seen A LOT of faux fur in the stores which is in my opinion a step in the right direction, but I also think that such a big and influencing company should show some more commitment and consistency. Reflecting the number of items, a company like Zara produces, it is quite obvious how even a few pieces with real fur sum up to thousands of tortured animals.
Personally, I’ve never been big of a fur fan, but those videos cleared my mind once more. It’s really depressing, how nowadays you can shop hardy anything in good conscience. I really hope, that’s going to change soon.
What else would a “Ministerium für Verbraucherschutz” be good for..?!
Modern Slavery
Most of us (students/young ppl) like cheap clothes and we all noticed the “made in vietnam/china/india/turkey…..” signs in our stuff. Obviously, the people working there to sew clothes for Europe or the US don’t get paid in our standards… But still, no one would really think that working conditions are AS bad, as they turned out to be.
August 2011. HUGE scandal. Zara is accused of alleged slave labor and child labor in Brazil. The press was full of it! Apparently, Inditex has approximately 50 suppliers in Brazil, which employ more than 7,000 workers.There are hundreds of factories in Sao Paulo state, producing garments for Brazil’s booming market. According to a BBC article, many of the workers are smuggled into Brazil from Bolivia and Peru. I found on a different blog information that, in search of a better life.
The “workers” left their countries in search of the “Brazilian dream.”
When they arrived in Brazil, they had to work long hours over a number of months just to pay off the cost of transportation to Brazil. During the operation, inspectors seized two notebooks filled with debt related to “pass” and “documents”, and “valleys” that caused employees to further increase their debt. The specific details show some of the wages received by employees: from $274 to $460, much less than the minimum wage in the country, which is $545.
15 people including a 14 year old teenager were released from slavery in two workshops – one located in the centre of Sao Paulo and another in the north. The investigation culminated in an inspection conducted at the end of June when 52 workers were found working under conditions similar to slavery in Americana, where the group sewed pants for Zara…
Turns out, Zara received accusations including illegal child labour, degrading, exhausting journeys of up to 16 hours daily and curtailment of freedom (prohibition of leaving the workplace without permission!!!).
According to Inditex, there will be an increase in the review of the production system to ensure there is not another case like this, but I highly doubt that since supervision of all the productions in Latin America would be WAY to costly. So I’ll keep my eyes open for any other cases like that because I think that if anything like this was to happen AGAIN, Zara will be in BIG trouble….
Pia said:
Left alone the fact that this blog as such as mentioned in the introduction represses the bling bling site of fashion and shows aspects behind the stage, this post is also well written and I actually myself didn´t know about this scandal of ZARA.. keep it!
nancy said:
Hi Inga,
this is a very well written piece of information.I was shocked while reading your post because I never knew that Zara was undergoing such accusations.The fact that you only express your own opinion is also amazing.
mirjastoldt said:
I think you did a great job on presenting a rather provocative and serious topic in a very objective matter. Your Introduction was very inviting and got me interested in your topic.
A thing you could have done, was to divide your post into two posts, then you would have had two shorter and interesting posts instead of one long one that might loose its touch at the end.
But overall it was a great post, with a great topic and I enjoyed reading it 🙂
alina said:
Hey Inga!
Good and provocative post! In my eyes its unnecessary to wear real fur and seeing that clip (havent seen that one before) just supported my opinion.
Also I havent heard of the Zara scandal but it kind of occured to me that clothes which are that cheap do not fall from a tree. I was several times shopping at Primark, they have sick prices!! Compared to Zara peanuts basically. But compared to Zara Primark is doing legal by having an ethical legal programme. So maybe its a cool opportunity to show how you can prevent acting like Zara in a way Primark does it 🙂
more information:
http://powder-puff-patrol.blogspot.com/2011/09/help-wieso-kann-primark-niedrigpreise.html
http://www.derhandel.de/news/unternehmen/pages/Textilhandel-Primark-waechst-mit-Billigmode-7845.html
Pingback: Sustainability in fashion « fashion2011marketing
Lagan Pillay said:
I never in a million years would’ve had the idea to look at things like this. This will make my life a bunch easier.
Darshana Natarajan said:
I never would have considered at things that way.
This will make my afternoon a bunch easier.
uk Fashion said:
Undeniably believe that which you said. Your favorite justification appeared to be on the net the easiest thing to be aware
of. I say to you, I certainly get annoyed while people consider worries that they plainly don’t know about. You managed to hit the nail upon the top and also defined out the whole thing without having side-effects , people could take a signal. Will likely be back to get more. Thanks